Nicolet Law Accident and Injury Lawyers
 Free Consultations | Calls Answered 24/7 
Nicolet Law Accident and Injury Lawyers

Built on Family.
Focused on Helping.
Dedicated to Winning.

We win or you don’t pay
500 ★★★★★ reviews

Nicolet Law office
SERVING WI & MN | Calls Answered 24/7 | Free Consultations 866-663-8774

5 Post-Accident Mistakes Victims Make When Talking to Insurance Companies

Injured? Get Nicolet.
Free case evaluation

5 Post-Accident Mistakes Victims Make When Talking to Insurance Companies

Car accident victim speaking with an insurance adjuster after a crash.

In the wake of a car accident, victims tend to be scared, overwhelmed, and unsure of what to do or say. Unfortunately, insurance companies are well aware of this, and they often take advantage of a victim’s vulnerable state. To avoid falling into the most common traps, the following is a list of things victims should refrain from doing or saying after an accident.

1. Saying sorry

It is best to avoid offering any kind of apology after being in an accident. While saying sorry is a reflex for many Midwesterners, accident victims should resist the urge. An apology has the potential to be interpreted as an admission of guilt or fault, even if it is clear the victim did not cause the accident. The reality is that insurance companies will do everything they can to protect their bottom line—including trying to assign fault to injured victims.

Instead of apologizing at the scene, consider expressing concern in other ways. Check in with the other people involved, ask them if they are all right, and offer them help with moving their car or other vehicle, if necessary.

It is also a bad idea to apologize to an insurance adjuster at any time. Sadly, these individuals listen for apologies they can manipulate into admissions of guilt, and they will take advantage of any opportunity a victim provides. Some insurance adjusters even go so far as to fish for an apology by asking whether a victim feels sorry about what happened.

2. Being dishonest or exaggerating

After an accident, the other driver’s insurance company will conduct an investigation to determine fault. This will involve an extensive analysis of a victim’s medical records and bills, police reports, and any statements provided by parties involved in the accident. Insurance companies will leave no stone unturned.

If the investigation unearths any discrepancy, falsehood, or exaggeration in the victim’s report, the insurance company will exploit it. For example, let’s say a woman is in a car accident on her way home from work. Even though she doesn’t really know how fast she had been driving or what the other driver had been doing before the accident occurred, she tells the police and the insurance company that she thinks she had been driving under the speed limit and that the other driver had been on his or her phone.

Unfortunately, the insurance company’s investigation reveals that the woman had been speeding when the accident happened. While the woman turned out to be right in saying that the other driver had been distracted, the fact that she misrepresented her speed will cast doubt on her word and may result in a lower settlement.

It is in an accident victim’s best interest to stick to the facts and say as little as possible to insurance adjusters. Being dishonest or inconsistent will give the at-fault driver’s insurance company leverage to minimize the amount of money they have to pay.

3. Giving a statement to the other driver’s insurance company

During the insurance company’s investigation, the adjuster may ask the victim to provide a statement about the claim. These statements are generally not helpful to victims, as they are an attempt to shift some blame away from the at-fault driver.

If a victim decides to give a statement, it is likely that the insurance carrier for the at-fault party will ask questions that are incredibly specific or difficult to answer. The purpose of this is to overwhelm the victim into providing information that may be harmful to his or her claim.

Accident victims are advised to consult with an attorney before agreeing to provide any kind of statement to another party’s insurance. While the insurance company might try to insist that a statement is necessary, the victim is not required to provide one to an at-fault provider. A personal injury attorney can help guide victims successfully through this portion of the claims process.

4. Settling too quickly

Insurance companies want to close accident cases as quickly as they can. In many instances, they will provide an initial settlement offer after the victim completes his or her treatment plan and all medical records and bills have been submitted. This initial offer tends to be the lowest amount the insurance company thinks a victim will accept.

Accident victims are advised to consult with a lawyer before accepting any offer from the at-fault driver’s insurance company. The initial offer frequently represents a starting point in the negotiation process, and a victim may be able to increase his or her settlement amount—especially if he or she proceeds with the help of an attorney.

5. Not hiring a lawyer

Some accident victims prefer to handle their claims without the use of an attorney. While that is perfectly reasonable, it is also important for victims to understand how invaluable a personal injury attorney can be to those navigating the claims process.

Many personal injury attorneys have years of experience fighting against the insurance companies. Unlike the insurance companies, a lawyer’s primary goal is to protect his or her clients. Any attorney worth his or her salt will stop at nothing to ensure accident victims receive the compensation they need to recover from their injuries.

Most personal injury attorneys offer free initial consultations, so there is no risk to scheduling a consult with a local lawyer. Also, accident and injury lawyers represent their clients on a contingency basis, which means that accident victims don’t have to pay attorney’s fees unless their lawyer wins their case.

Hiring a Personal Injury Attorney After an Accident

When a car accident upends a person’s life, it can be hard to remember what should and should not be done or said. Hiring a personal injury attorney can help accident victims navigate the claims process and avoid falling into the most common traps with insurance companies.

Licensed attorneys know how to handle the insurance companies and will make sure victims receive the compensation they deserve.



Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law


Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law


Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law
More Than
Million recovered for our clients
5 star reviews
More Than
years in business


Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law
$0.00 - denial*


Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law


Result with Nicolet Law 


Offer before Nicolet Law
YouTube video

What our clients say about us

powered by BirdEye
more testimonials

Awards & Recognitions

Nicolet Law Office is honored to have been nominated for numerous awards for excellence in service and client satisfaction. Our attorneys have appeared in such prestigious lists as Top 40 Under 40 and Rising Stars. While we’re thankful to have the support of industry peers and independent third-party organizations, nothing beats the feeling of gratitude we share with clients when we can make a positive impact on their lives.

From our blog


Contact us today to request a free case evaluation with a dedicated local attorney. With twelve convenient office locations throughout Minnesota and Wisconsin, accessing award-winning legal services has never been easier. If you have a medical condition that prevents you from traveling, we would be happy to meet you at your home or schedule a private virtual consultation.


Tell us about your case

We’ll review your case details and contact you with an action plan.
Fields marked with an * are required
Brief description of your legal issue.
Disclaimer: The use of the internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

13 locations in Wisconsin and Minnesota to serve you

Wisconsin State Icon

Wisconsin Locations:

402 Graham Ave.
Suite 305
Eau Claire, WI 54701

Phone: (715) 835-5959
Map & Directions

2300 Riverside Dr,
Suite 105
Green Bay, WI 54301
Phone: (920)-504-3655
Map & Directions

517 2nd Street
Unit #205
Hudson, WI 54016

Phone: 715-226-6158
Map & Directions

205 5th Avenue S,
Suite 209,
La Crosse, WI 54601

Phone: 608-527-0876
Map & Directions

1500 Madison Ave.
Suite 220
New Richmond, WI 54017

Phone: 715-226-6164
Map & Directions

337 North Main Street
Rice Lake, WI 54868

Phone: (715) 790-1114
Map & Directions

215 S 2nd St #20
River Falls, WI 54022

Phone: (715) 716-5869
Map & Directions

1200 Tower Ave.
Superior, WI 54880

Phone: (715) 718-2969
Map & Directions

408 3rd Street
Suite 303
Wausau, WI 54403

Phone: (715) 716-5092
Map & Directions

Minnesota State Icon

Minnesota Locations:

306 West Superior Street,
Suite 606 West
Duluth, MN 55802

Phone: (218) 729-0628
Map & Directions

Howard Court Bldg.
302 Howard Street, Suite 123
Hibbing, MN 55746

Phone: 218-217-0659
Map & Directions

23 - 4th Street SE
Suite #217
Minneapolis, MN 55414
Phone: (612) 446-3999
Map & Directions

724 Bielenberg Drive
Suite 126
Woodbury, MN 55125

Phone: (651) 815-0017
Map & Directions

Wisconsin and Minnesota’s Local Award-Winning Injury and Disability 
© 2022 Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers, S.C. All Rights Reserved.
If we do not get you a recovery in your case, you will not be responsible for any attorney fees, but you still may be responsible for costs expended on your behalf, such as filing fees, medical records, etc.
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram