How to Tell Who is At Fault in a Car Accident

Emergency stop sign near two persons arguing about car accident on road
How to Tell Who is At Fault in a Car Accident

After a car accident, one of the most important things to determine is who was at fault. This can have a huge impact on insurance claims, legal proceedings, and your financial well-being. However, how to tell who is at fault in a car accident isn't always straightforward, especially if the other driver denies responsibility. Worse yet, maybe the other driver or their insurance company is trying to blame you for the crash even though you weren’t responsible.

If you’re running into these challenges, you should contact an experienced car accident attorney in your area for a free consultation. They can help you understand your rights, gather evidence, and establish fault on the appropriate parties. They can also deal with the insurance companies and fight to get you the compensation you deserve. Don't wait, though. The sooner you have legal representation, the better the chances they can build a strong case for you and file your claim within any applicable deadlines.

Read on to learn how insurance companies, the courts, and lawyers determine fault in car accidents and what you need to know to protect yourself.

Injured? Get Nicolet.

Understanding the Basics of Fault

At its core, "fault" in a car accident means that someone's negligence or wrongdoing caused the collision to occur. Proving fault is critically important for a couple reasons:

  1. To file a claim with the at-fault driver's insurance and get them to pay for your damages and injuries.
  2. To pursue legal action against the at-fault driver if needed to fully recover your losses.

Without clear evidence of fault, you may have a very difficult time getting compensated for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other costs. The at-fault party's insurance will likely deny your claim. That's why it's so important to establish a strong case for fault from the beginning.

Common Scenarios and Determining Fault

While every accident is unique, there are some common crash scenarios where fault can often be more readily assigned. Let's look at a few:

Rear-End Collisions

In a typical rear-end accident, the general rule is that the driver of the rear vehicle is at fault. This is because all drivers have a basic duty to follow at a safe distance and be able to stop in time to avoid colliding with the car in front of them.

However, there are some exceptions to this rule. The lead driver may share some blame if they:

While rear-end collisions often point to the rear driver being at fault, the full context matters. An experienced attorney can help determine if the lead driver shares any responsibility.

Left-Turn Accidents

When a driver makes a left turn and collides with an oncoming vehicle, the turning driver is usually found to be at fault. Vehicles going straight have the right-of-way, and it's the turning driver's duty to yield until it's safe to turn.

But again, there are exceptions. The oncoming driver may be found fully or partially at fault if they were:

Witness statements and evidence from the scene can be key in left-turn cases to show if the oncoming driver's reckless actions made the collision unavoidable for the turning car.

Failing to Yield Right-of-Way

Generally, if a driver fails to yield the right-of-way and it results in an accident, they will be found at fault. Common scenarios include:

  • Running a stop sign or red light and T-boning another vehicle
  • Failing to yield when merging onto a highway or changing lanes
  • Turning right on red without coming to a complete stop first
  • Failing to yield to pedestrians in a crosswalk

Disregarding traffic control devices or failing to properly yield is strong evidence of fault. However, the other driver may share responsibility if they were also breaking traffic laws at the time.

Speeding and Reckless Driving

Speeding is one of the leading causes of accidents. When a driver is going too fast for conditions, they have less time to react and are more likely to lose control and cause a crash. Speeding is often a main factor in assigning fault.

Other aggressive maneuvers like weaving through traffic, sudden lane changes, and tailgating also point to negligence. If reckless actions directly led to the accident, the court or insurance company may deem that the driver was predominantly at fault, even if the other driver made minor mistakes.

Evidence to Support Fault Determination

Proving fault often comes down to gathering sufficient evidence that shows what really happened. The more you can document, the stronger your case. Key pieces of evidence include:

  • Police Reports: Always call the police after an accident, even if damage seems minor. Police reports offer an official, third-party account of the crash, including driver and witness statements, citations issued, and the officer's assessment of fault. While police don't have final say, insurers and courts give their determinations significant weight. If a report concludes the other driver was fully at fault, that can go a long way in supporting your claim.
  • Witness Statements: Bystanders or others not directly involved in the accident can provide invaluable objective insights. Get contact information for any witnesses at the scene. Their statement backing up your version of events can be crucial evidence, especially if fault is disputed.
  • Traffic Camera Footage: Many intersections and roadways now have surveillance cameras. Check if there were any that may have captured the accident. Footage showing the other driver running a red light or veering into your lane can be indisputable proof of fault.
  • Vehicle Damage and Markings: Take ample photos of the damage to both vehicles from multiple angles. The location and extent of damage can say a lot about how the accident occurred and who likely struck whom. Also photograph any skid marks, debris, or road markings. Measurements and analysis can potentially show if a driver swerved, braked too late, or was following too closely.
  • Driver Admissions: Sometimes a driver will acknowledge fault, such as saying "I'm sorry, I didn't see you" or "I got distracted." Document and share with your attorney any "admission against interest" by the other driver suggesting they caused the crash. Their own words can be powerful evidence.

An attorney can also formally request driver cellphone records and data from the vehicle's black box which may further show fault, such as if the driver was texting or didn't brake until impact.

Comparative and Contributory Negligence

In some accidents, both drivers may share some degree of fault. When that happens, states have different rules on how it affects financial recovery:

Comparative Negligence

Comparative Negligence: Most states, including Minnesota, follow a "modified comparative negligence" model. You can recover compensation so long as you’re not 50% or 51% at fault, depending on the state. If you are found to be partially at fault, your compensation is reduced by your percentage of blame. Some states have a "pure comparative fault" rule where you can recover compensation even if you are 99% at fault.

Contributory Negligence: A handful of states have a far stricter "contributory negligence" rule. Under this law, if you are found even 1% at fault, you can be completely barred from recovering any compensation from the other driver.

An attorney can help determine how your state's negligence rules may impact your case. These laws are complex and proving the other driver was fully at fault is crucial to maximize your financial recovery.

It's always advisable to consult with an attorney after an accident. However, you really need to get legal representation if any of these apply to your case:

  • Fault is unclear, or the other driver or their insurance company disputes fault
  • The accident involved serious injuries or significant property damage
  • The insurance company is denying your claim or making lowball settlement offers
  • The insurance company is blaming you for the accident you believe was not your fault

Remember, insurance companies are out for profit and will try to minimize payouts whenever possible. An attorney skilled in auto accident claims can advocate for your interests and work to get you full and fair compensation.

Choose an attorney with deep experience handling car accidents and a track record of successful results. Look for a firm that offers free consultations, works on contingency (no fee unless you win), and can take your case to trial if needed.

Contact an Experienced Car Accident Attorney Right Away

No one expects to be in an accident. But if you are in a car crash, you need to know how to protect yourself and navigate the legal system to get the best possible outcome. Having a skilled lawyer on your side from the beginning can make a world of difference.

At Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers, our experienced personal injury attorneys can handle every aspect of your case so you can focus on healing and moving forward with your life. We promise to treat you and your family with compassion, empathy, and respect. You can trust us to work diligently to hold the at-fault driver fully accountable for your injuries and losses and increase your chances of obtaining maximum compensation.

Don't accept an unfair settlement or risk losing out on the compensation you deserve because the insurance company is trying to place undue blame on you for the crash. Contact us today for a free, no-obligation consultation. We'll review your case, answer your questions, and discuss your legal options. You won't pay anything upfront for us to handle your case, and you only pay attorney fees if we recover compensation for you.